Title. Mathematically, what would you call a "number"? Where do you draw the line? Complex numbers? Dual numbers? Quaternions? Transfinite cardinals?
I think it's a good question - numbers don't really have a formal mathematical definition, so it's interesting seeing the opinions of different people. I went around and asked a bunch of people, and this is the result.
yours truly
To me, it's simple - a number is an element of a field.1
A field is a set with two operations, dubbed addition and multiplication (\gasp\). They follow the usual group theory axioms of associativity, commutativity and the existence of inverses and identity,2 with the one extra special caviat that multiplication is distributive over addition. You know, expanding brackets?
$$a(b + c) = ab + ac$$
This is the group theoretic equivalent of duck typing. If it quacks like a number, it is a number. That's satisfying enough for me, I think.
I'll admit I'm not completely original with my definition of a number (obviously). I stole it from a poll - I think it was the second most picked option, which certainly fuels my confidence.
my computer science teacher (NFE)
- "A number is anything which can be represented by decimal digits, with a decimal point."
- Attempted to give me a Backus-Naur form definition for
<number>. A surprisingly satisfying definition for real numbers, but you can only add so many new grammar rules to account for complex numbers, dual numbers, qua- - At least they didn't say "data".
- Ultimately I think a representational view of numbers is limiting and can never be accurate. Mathematics certainly isn't prescriptive.
Judgement: 4/10. Pretty much what I expected from someone who teaches this godforsaken A level.
my pure math teacher (JCH)
- Refused to give me an answer (not even $\mathbb{C}$, really?)
- Upon hearing my opinion, debated that a matrix could be a number given enough constraints and definitions - I argued a matrix with those constraints would be a number. Quaternions, anyone?3
- Argued that when one says "$e^x$ where $x$ is a number", nobody pictures a matrix. I said "$x$ is a number" is poorly defined and almost definitely not what you mean anyways.4
- Still refused to answer, complaining it was "too philosophical".
- You forgot your field theory lectures? Okay, I forgot my FP1 vectors content.
Judgement: 3/10. Fun conversation, but no answer is no answer.
my findings
What I found most interesting wasn't the mathematical opinion of teachers and nerds, but rather the way the average person looks at a number.
Language, like some aspects of math, is descriptive, not prescriptive. In the same way the dictionary is more of a map for language than a rulebook, the meaning behind terms like number - especially to someone not really concerned with the specifics of field theory 😠- provides a little context for what mathematics means to people.
You figure out pretty quickly that to most people, a number is supposed to represent a real world fact, like a measurement or quantity. This tracks pretty well with what people expect of maths as a discipline - utility in solving problems, but with little merit in further exploration. I would make a grandiose statement about the true purpose of maths, except I think it takes a couple more years of learning for field theory to become useful. For now, the hard truth is that these people are correct, but it won't stop me.
-
PLEASE don't check Wikipedia for the definition of a field. The first paragraph is literally "a field is a set that behaves like the rational numbers". I promise my argument is not a cop-out. <
-
i.e. a field is a group under addition with identity "zero", and all nonzero elements form a group under multiplication. <
-
I know I'm really hung up on quaternions. I had to use them a lot, okay? <
-
I'm also now realising that his notion of a number being "something which you can raise $e$ to the power of" shows an implicit bias towards the complex numbers, and not things like cardinals. <